Long Pause Media. A Division of FlightBridgeED.
Long Pause Media A Division of FlightBridgeED®
Ordinary Ops Medic

HemoDIEnamics

Part 1 (Again)

Ordinary Ops Medic

(The original version of this appeared on LinkedIn in June 2026, and it sucked. This is a rewrite and an update).

Just this past June, Dr. Zaffer Qasim put out a paper and tagged me in a post on LinkedIn that got my wheels turning (thanks for the shout out, Doc!). It was about placing an art line in the common femoral artery and identifying shock earlier and avoiding getting behind the patient's physiology. It made me think of how we in the prehospital setting can maybe see shock coming without the use of an art line and make decisions based on the physiology instead of an arbitrary number written in a protocol.

Murali S, Cannon J, Joergensen S, et al. Video review analysis of early common femoral arterial access in trauma: Can we identify occult shock? Injury. 2026 Mar 25:113169. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2026.113169. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 41896154.

Nota Bene

The intent is to see shock manifesting faster and eliminate the thought process of "Once the blood pressure gets to 90, then I can do something meaningful." 

Is it easier to support and prolong the compensatory phase or try to recover them in the decompensated phase?

 

Compensated Shock

Decompensated Shock

Pulse Pressure

Narrowing < 30

Narrow or Wide

MAP

> 65

< 65

Shock Index

0.7 - 0.9

> 1.0

ETCo2

>27

<22-27


Cognitio rei

 The Tables Have Turned

ATLS/PHTLS tables were made for education, not to inform clinical practice and protocol. They make it easier to teach shock, but they miscategorized a large percentage of our patients. But are we giving them too much credit? Parks et al and the Mutschler papers cited below demonstrate the flaws in the tables. Parks found that almost half of patients in hemorrhagic shock do not meet the defined parameters of these programs, they were largely uncategorizable. Mutchler found that 9.3% of the patients fit neatly into any category, of that group ~90% of them were just Class I. Less than 1% of the entire study population represented classes II, III, and IV. 

This was brought to our attention more than a decade ago! Yet, it is still in the education and protocol lexicon. They are even testable as written. As we all know, there is academia and there is what we are dealing with at all hours of the day with all manner of patients suffering from shock.

110 is the new 90. Not just for those with TBI, but everyone in shock. We know that a patient with "normal" vitals can still demonstrate a shock index that warrants attention. In fact, it is suggested that a SBP < 110 in our trauma population is associated with increased mortality and the SBP of 90 as the definition of hypotension is inadequate.

These tables are also completely useless when the patient is elderly, pediatric, a super fit athlete, or the chronic hypertensive patient.

 I think there are other elements to look at that can cue us to start aggressive resuscitation sooner, before the blood pressure changes dramatically. On a personal note, I don't think I have ever used a class of shock to describe a patient at handover or in a chart, and I can only imagine how much of a doober I would sound like if I did. They have always either been in shock or not.

·       Parks J PMID: 31419641.

·       Mutschler M PMID: 23302502.

·       Mutschler PMID: 25284231.

·       Mutschler  PMID: 23938104

 

Why the Obsession With Speed?

There is a two fold issue in correcting shock or oxygen debt: depth and duration. How deep in shock were they and how long did they stay there before their condition improved. Shock is not really about low blood pressures, it is about oxygen delivery, deficit, and debt. Lack of oxygen delivery = a deficit. Lack of oxygen delivery after consumption exceeds supply = oxygen debt.

 For the patient in shock, the amount of time they spend in an oxygen deprived state incurs an amount of oxygen debt. Oxygen debt is not just what is left after we have restored perfusion and adequate forward flow, it has been accumulating with interest since the onset. This takes time (with good perfusion) to correct. The debt starts the instant that the rate of oxygen consumption exceeds the rate of oxygen delivered at the cellular level. Think of this as having a maxed out credit card on payday. You can make a payment, but still remain in debt and incur interest charges.

The longer they are in debt and the deeper the debt, the harder it is to recover. Organ dysfunction is essentially bankruptcy from the interest charges of inflammation, coagulopathy, and endothelial damage. Barbee et al demonstrated via canine models that paying back 75% of the oxygen debt within 2 hours of onset is necessary to prevent organ damage and dysfunction.

·       Bjerkvig PMID: 27100755

·       Spinella DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-20820-2 --> a must have for any clinician.

·       Barbee PMID: 20081495

 Hemorrhagic shock - a holistic view | Geir Strandenes | Big Sick 2018

 


Vacre ad actum

 

Metric

Compensated Shock

Decompensated Shock

Pulse Pressure

Narrowing < 30

Narrow or Wide

MAP

> 65

< 65

Shock Index

0.7 - 0.9

> 1.0

ETCo2

>27

<22-27

 

Reset the Table

A note about the numbers and calculations here: none of these should be evaluated once or in isolation and then trigger a decision. These should be trended (give it 5 - 10 minutes) and put together for the most complete clinical picture possible to support a decision. The most concerning piece of information to take away from the trend is not the fact that they may be trending downward toward badness, it is the velocity of the change. How quickly did the shock index rise or  ETCo2 drop to 26. It is telling you how fast they are decompensating, unlike the SBP which merely tells you that they have decompensated (or not… yet).

It is important to note that this is not perfect. A known weakness is the reliance on NIBP to obtain blood pressure numbers which we know are not precise with oscillometric devices. There are many calculations taking place and the worse the patient's condition, the worse the math. The general consensus is that they over-estimate and may mask instability. 

Having said that, pulse pressure, shock index, and ETCo2 can tell the tale of shock much faster than waiting on the patient to decompensate to the degree the blood pressure drops. This also gives you 3 data points to support decisions rather than one arbitrary number. The logic trail of why you did something is easier to follow with three data points (See Pete Blaber's work on the Logic of Why). This is important if you are using a disciplined pattern recognition approach to make a decision that will confront shortcomings in established protocols. 

The MAP is a mainstay of resuscitation guidance and still relevant. Having said that, its utility is established and I won't belabor the point here.

1.) Pulse Pressure

Math: PP = SBP - DBP

Results: Narrow: <30   Wide: 50-60 (pathologically wide)

A snapshot of stroke volume and vascular tone, pulse pressure is one of the easiest ways to determine if the patient is in serious trouble or not. If you look at the blood pressure results like this:  SBP = stroke volume / DBP = vascular tone  it is easier to get your head around what it is telling you.

At first, in shock, the pulse pressure is narrow. Meaning that the SBP and DBP are closer to each other (generally <30-40).  Which makes some physiologic sense as the initial response to hypoperfusion (or hypovolemia in hemorrhage) is to vasoconstrict in an attempt to increase (or maintain as close to normal) the output of the LV.

The question you should have when the PP is narrow is: They are compensating for how much longer?

In later stages of shock, the pulse pressure widens. Not because we have improved their intravascular volume and therefore their stroke volume, but because the DBP is taking a dive.This can be due to one or a combination of these issues: they have exhausted their catecholamine supply, or they have severe endothelial damage (endotheliopathy).

  • Hamzaoui PMID: 30447892.

  • Ospina-Tascón PMID: 32296976

  • Putowski  PMID: 40537864

 

2.) Shock Index

Math: HR / SBP(standard) 0.7 - 0.9 (trouble is coming). >1.0 = shock

Math: HR / MAP (modified) 0.7 - 1.3 (>1.3 is associated with high mortality)

Results: the higher the index, the worse the shock state.

I am a fan of the mSI since it takes the DBP into account and gives a more complete picture than the SBP alone does. Having said that, in a tight situation I will 100% look to see if the HR is > than the SBP and if so I know the patient is in shock. What I love about this measurement is that it is OBJECTIVE. You do math and the number is what it is.

 Speaking of numbers, a SI of 0.7 - 0.9 is SHOCK. They just have intact compensatory mechanisms.  That range is the window of opportunity to make a significant impact with an aggressive move. At 1.0, you are forced to chase the patient's physiology. The sooner you start trying to move the needle, the more likely it is to move. The longer you wait to make a move the less likely it is to work as well as the patient needs it to.

· Can be confounded by blunted tachycardia in the elderly. Rely instead on the pulse pressure.

·  Can be confounded by other contributors to tachycardia (pain, anxiety, etc). The most correct thing to do is to err on the side of tachycardia is in response to hemorrhage until proven otherwise. Dennis and Max unpack this nicely on the PFC Podcast: 

 Don’t Wait for Hypotension: Resuscitation Decision-Making

 ·       Singh PMID: 25317389;

·       Liu PMID: 25215048

·       Mutschler PMID: 23938104

·       Little PMID: 7640820

3.) ETCo2

Ranges: 35-45 normal

Results:  25 - 30 = Shock w/ compensation

              <25 = decompensation

 What other tool gives you a glimpse of ventilation status, cardiac output, and metabolism all at once? We don't have one. ETCo2 for the critically ill patient is not an option, in my opinion. It signals instability and shock long before the SBP gets to the standard SBP of 90 trigger.  

You are specifically looking for low end tidal numbers in the absence of a dramatic tachypnea. Are these patients tachypneic? Sure. It is expected. But… hypotension (SBP 80) + ETCO2 < 25-30 should not have you thinking about respiratory issues, it should scream “imminent cardiovascular collapse” at you.

 ·       Johns PMID: 29478573.

·       Öztürk PMID: 36161601

·       Kheng PMID: 22828152

·       Hunter PMID: 24332900