Servant leadership came on the scene to invert the hierarchies in place for so long in the workplace. It was supposed to orient leaders toward their teams and the individuals that comprise them, and away from building their own careers. It was meant to focus on getting the best out of the team and helping the individual be successful instead of using the team to build their own success.
A great theory that has trouble proving itself in practice. In fact, the vast majority of people that I have worked for who say this is their leadership style and strategy are merely saying it because they think it sounds good and is the “right thing” to say… it’s lip service.
It's performative.
I will preface everything I am about to say with this: taking care of the people in your charge is a basic expectation of all leaders. It is simply good leadership. The style or theory you subscribe to can help enable you to do well at it.
How Leaders Are Poisoning Their Teams With “Servant Leadership”
Leaders who use “people pleasing” as a primary operating and management style (they call it servant leadership though) build the functional equivalent of an adult day care. Likely caused by a total lack of spine and intestinal fortitude, lest someone not like what they did. That manager would die before they inconvenienced one of their team members. They are petrified of the thought of disciplining someone for any sort of infraction. They ignore the slow erosion of trust and psychological safety that is destroying the team. “As long as they’re happy,” is their strategy.
They believe that likability has a direct correlation to success. “They like me, therefore I am a good leader.” “I get along with everyone, I am successful.” I call this likership, it is not leadership.
They “yes” their teams to death, and in reality are wholly subservient to the team. Held hostage to the whims and opinions of the people in their charge. In one organization I watched the team hold their leaders hostage to their satisfaction by letting shifts go uncovered or calling out “sick” as retaliation against the organization because of a decision they disagreed with. It was totally bananas to witness… and yes, I watched that leader go back and retract their policy and operational changes to keep the peace.
Getting it Wrong
There is nothing inherently wrong with treating people like human beings and ensuring that you are approachable. There's no need to walk around like a tyrannical bully all day. That’s just human decency. But sacrificing the effectiveness of the organization to keep everyone “happy” simply does not work, and it goes against a core tenant of leadership: mission accomplishment. As Jocko would say, “there are two kinds of leaders, effective and ineffective…”
Where the concept of servant leadership loses its impact:
As an excuse for being passive.
As cover for leaning on the team to make all of the decisions because you can’t make the tough calls.
As an explanation for avoiding dealing with people problems.
As the reason for fixing every problem and putting out every fire for the team.
To be performative and pay it lip service to “say” this is how you lead when you actually aren’t.
Getting It Right
Servant leadership and similar styles are not about being popular or well liked. It is about creating the environment where the results you need are possible. It is how you serve the team. Using your influence and organizational resources (e.g. money) to enhance the team almost never backfires.
What servant leadership actually is:
Heavy investment in training the team for high level execution.
Removing obstacles to high performance (toxic teammates etc.)
Building mutual trust and respect between leadership and the team.
Communicating and unifying the team behind a shared vision.
Enforcing clear boundaries, standards, and expectations… consistently.
Context Is Key
You have to adapt this practice to your operational environment and the current operational context. Meaning, if you are a shift commander of an emergency response organization, don’t try to lead like you run are running a tech start-up. Likewise, if you are leading a shift as a charge nurse, don’t act like you are leading a bayonet charge in a battle.
Doing It Well Is About Balance
Balancing the needs of the team with the execution of the mission is a tall order, but it is why you are in a leadership position. You have to be detached enough to be able to pull back and see what needs to happen and budget the team’s effort to make it so. Balance is knowing when you need to pivot versus when to sit tight. Knowing when to be patient and when to take command. Knowing when to coach and when to admonish.
Balancing the need for accountability with operational requirements (you cant just fire people on the spot willy nilly without a plan for replacement). → Be smart.
Balancing the need for future change with the need for stability right now. → Be deliberate
Balance collaboration and deliberate decision making. → Be patient.
Balance supportive and assertive action. → Be there.
Take Home Points
Likership is not leadership. You have to think about what is best for: the mission, the team, and yourself IN THAT ORDER. Consider the impact to those three elements whenever you decide to do something or not do something. That is how you serve the team.
